Monday 2007/11/12
7:39 PM

Categories: Apple, OS X, PS3, Technology's Betrayal, Video Games

Streaming from Mac to PS3


(Photo by _Idris_)

Took a stab at setting up media streaming from the Mac to the PS3 and found it to be relatively straightforward. There’s a few options for doing this, the first being Elgato’s EyeConnect and the other being Twonky Vision. EyeConnect appeared to be a little more polished and installs as a System Preference Pane, so I tried that one first. Unfortunately, while I could browse my media just fine, playing the media usually didn’t work. Occasionally I would get a song to play or mp3 to load, but most of the time I ended up with a generic network error message. I’ve noted a few online forum messages that imply that the latest firmware update (v2.0) to the PS3 seems to have broken things for EyeConnect, so hopefully this is just classic blip in the relatively new space of media streaming and they’ll have that patched up quickly.

In the meantime, I’ve installed the Twonky Vision media server, which runs quite well. Management is done via a web panel, and so far playback has been pretty solid aside from the occasional hiccup. Resetting the media server’s client table usually solves those issues. The drawback is that for some reason AAC files (even unprotected ones) don’t play – they’re listed as “Unsupported Data” in menu listings. Thankfully most of my music is in regular old mp3 files, but it’s still a bit disappointing given that the PS3 actually can play AAC files just fine. EyeConnect supports unprotected AAC, but of course getting it to actually play the files without constant network errors was impossible.So this solution works ok for now, and I’m going to ride out the 30-day demo on the Twonky Vision software while keeping an eye out for EyeConnect updates before plunking down for one of them. It’s nice to be able to route my media to the home system without using an iPod dock (or an AppleTV).


Responses


Nate

Saturday 2008/09/13 9:08 AM

There are other versions of software available besides just Twonkymedia, Tversity, and EyeConnect.

http://blog.hillbillyhardware.net/?page_id=34

I have worked quite a bit with several of these programs. But Twonkymedia is about as solid as you can get for streaming if you are on Windows XP. Now Mac users on the other hand, may want to try Medialink.


ds

Saturday 2008/09/13 9:55 AM

Nate -

I ended up trying Medialink and I’ve shifted to using it. The only catch is that MP4 files stutter when streamed. Other types seem to stream just fine. I read an interview a while back with the Sony firmware engineers and they said that the pipeline for video processing is different for streamed content versus items saved on disk or on a connected drive, so for video I’ve just started dumping stuff onto the PS3. The hard drive is so easy to upgrade that running out of space isn’t a worry. I still stream music and photos, however. Twonkymedia has a better indexing system in my opinion – for music you can browse artists quickly by letter, whereas with Medialink you have to scroll through the whole list.


Nate

Thursday 2008/09/18 5:27 PM

I haven’t ran into any issues with MP4 files, but there is a chance it can happen. I ran into a few issues with slight lag between voice and audio. Usually pausing and starting it cleared it right up. If you are going through the wireless, that may be why. But if you know much about the two, then I reckon you are smart enough to know to not use wireless for your streaming needs.

Yes Twonky has the indexing as you mentioned, but if you have a lot of artists, it is dang hard to pin some of them down for the song you are looking for. For example, I have an album called Final Fantasy stored on my hard drive. It contains a lot of remixes from OCremix.org which entails many different artist names. So you can see how having 200 different artist names for some remixes would be very frustrating to search through for the song you want. If you don’t have this type of situation, folder viewing is so much more simple for me.

I am glad you enjoy Medialink. It works well for everything I need. But maybe XBMC will provide something better for us all. Check the link.

http://blog.hillbillyhardware.net/?p=363


Leave a Response